Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Reviewed Nov 20, 2026 New

Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"

Our favorite boxer brief. Supremely comfortable, without a weak spot, and the horizontal fly is a genuine pleasure.

By the Gentleman's Drawer editors · No. 1 of 5 boxer briefs we have reviewed
Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"
Our score8.2out of 10
RankingNo. 1of 5 in Boxer Briefs
Price per pair$34.00regular price, Nov 20, 2026

Our take

Our top boxer brief, and the one we would recommend to almost anyone. Per Tommy John it is 86% Pima cotton with a stay-put waistband and the brand's horizontal Quick Draw fly, which is a genuine highlight in daily use. It is the most comfortable boxer brief we have worn and has no weak point to apologize for. On, it looks smooth and polished, the kind of pair that makes getting dressed feel a little more intentional.

The scorecard

Comfort9
Pouch8
Fabric8
Style8
Durability8
Waistband8
Value7.6

Scored out of 10.

Where it shines

Comfort

Where it falls short

No real weak spot.

The details

As Tommy John describes it, checked Nov 20, 2026.

Pair
Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"
Regular price
$34 (regular listed price)
Detail
86% Pima cotton, 14% spandex
Detail
Horizontal Quick Draw fly
Detail
Stay-put waistband, per Tommy John
Detail
6-inch inseam
Source
Tommy John

What buyers say

★★★★★★★★★★ 4.57/5 from 2,107 reviews · Tommy John product page, Nov 20, 2026

Highlighted reviews praise the fit, the material and a length that does not ride up. Some recent reviewers report loose threads or frayed waistbands, and inconsistent sizing. Read the reviews.

Customer opinion from Tommy John’s own review section, kept separate from ours. More on what buyers say.

Where it ranks

The full boxer briefs ranking · More from Tommy John

How we review

We wore this pair, washed it and wore it again before writing a word. Nothing a brand gives us guarantees a good review, and we return to pairs as brands update them. How we test.