Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Split image: pale folded stack on navy fabric, dark folded stack on burgundy fabric
Holiday gift guide 2026

Underwear Gifts for the Man Who Hates New Underwear

He swears his old pairs are fine. These soft, flattering underwear gifts will change his mind, from Tommy John, lululemon, Saxx, Mack Weldon, Bombas and Duluth.

By the Gentleman's Drawer editors · Prices checked Nov 20, 2026

Every household has one: the man who insists his decade-old pairs are perfectly fine, thank you. The secret is a pair so soft he forgets he is wearing it, and so flattering he catches himself in the mirror.

These are the pairs most likely to win him over, and to retire the old ones for good.

Before you buy

Check the waist size on the tag of a pair he already wears, then compare it with the brand’s own size chart. If you are unsure of his cut, stay close to what is already in his drawer. Our size guide has more.

The picks at a glance

The picks

Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"
No. 1 · Worn and reviewed by us

Tommy John Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6"

The pair most likely to convert him

Cool, featherlight cotton, a mid-length leg that stays exactly where it should and a sideways fly he will wonder how he lived without. It looks tailored and feels like nothing at all, which is precisely what a skeptic needs.

Price
From $34 (some colours $36) regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Our review
Read our review
Buyer rating
4.57 of 5 from 2,107 reviews on Tommy John's site, checked Nov 20, 2026
lululemon Always In Motion Boxer Brief 3"
No. 2 · Worn and reviewed by us

lululemon Always In Motion Boxer Brief 3"

Barely there, and very flattering

Ultra-soft modal, a waistband designed not to dig in and a short, sculpted leg that gives him a lean, athletic line. Comfortable enough to forget, handsome enough to notice.

Price
$34 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Some colours on sale when we checked
Our review
Read our review
Saxx Vibe Xtra Soft Comfort Boxer Brief
No. 3 · Gift pick · not yet worn by us

Saxx Vibe Xtra Soft Comfort Boxer Brief

Soft support, done properly

Saxx's best-selling Vibe Xtra Soft boxer brief pairs a buttery EcoVero fabric with the brand's BallPark Pouch and a leg designed not to ride up. Supportive, smooth and easy to love from the first wear.

Price
$36 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
On sale when we checked
Tommy John Second Skin Luxe Rib Trunk 4"
No. 4 · Gift pick · not yet worn by us

Tommy John Second Skin Luxe Rib Trunk 4"

A ribbed trunk with a little texture

Tommy John's silky Second Skin fabric in a fine rib that adds airflow and a subtle, tactile texture. The contour pouch flatters, the waistband stays put, and the overall effect is quietly luxurious.

Price
$40 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Mack Weldon AIRKNITˣ Boxer Brief
No. 5 · Gift pick · not yet worn by us

Mack Weldon AIRKNITˣ Boxer Brief

Light, cool and athletic

Mack Weldon's AIRKNITˣ boxer brief is its lightest, most breathable pair, knitted to move air where he needs it most. A sleek fit with a sporty edge, ideal for the man who runs warm.

Price
$34 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Bombas Men's Cotton Modal Blend Boxer
No. 6 · Worn and reviewed by us

Bombas Men's Cotton Modal Blend Boxer

For the man who will not give up his boxers

Keep the loose cut he trusts and change everything else. Bombas makes its cotton-modal boxer softer and cut closer than the old faithfuls, so it looks deliberate and feels wonderful.

Price
$28 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Our review
Read our review
lululemon Always In Motion Boxer Brief 5"
No. 7 · Worn and reviewed by us

lululemon Always In Motion Boxer Brief 5"

A little more leg, a lot more polish

The same soft modal and no-dig waistband as lululemon's trunk, in a 5-inch leg that sits neatly on the thigh. Athletic, clean and comfortable from desk to gym.

Price
$34 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Our review
Read our review
Duluth Trading Co Men's Buck Naked Boxer Briefs
No. 8 · Buyer favourite · not yet worn by us

Duluth Trading Co Men's Buck Naked Boxer Briefs

The public's comfort champion

Duluth's Buck Naked boxer brief has earned 4.8 out of 5 across 18,966 reviews on the brand's site. Light, stretchy and quick to dry, with a gusset designed for movement. A gift for the practical man who values comfort above all.

Price
$24.95 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
On sale when we checked
Buyer rating
4.8 of 5 from 18,966 reviews on Duluth's site, checked Nov 20, 2026
Mack Weldon 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer
No. 9 · Worn and reviewed by us

Mack Weldon 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer

The soft knit boxer

A boxer cut from soft cotton jersey, so it drapes and moves like his favourite T-shirt while still looking sharp. The relaxed cut he loves, in a far more handsome form.

Price
$34 regular price, checked Nov 20, 2026
Our review
Read our review

Prices are each brand’s regular price, checked on the date shown. Many brands run holiday sales, so you may pay less. Our verdicts come from pairs we have worn and washed ourselves. Picks marked ‘not yet worn by us’ are described from the brand’s own details and, where shown, published customer ratings.

More holiday gift guides