Gentleman's DrawerBetter underwear, properly judged
Brand deep dive

Tommy John: the brand guide.

It began with an undershirt that would not stay tucked. Today it is one of the most complete underwear ranges a man can buy. I have worn every style. Here is how to choose.

By the editor of Gentleman’s Drawer · Nov 21, 2026
Tommy John Second Skin Luxe Rib 4 inch trunks in black, dress blues and chive green, product photoLuxe Rib 4″ Trunk in Black, Dress Blues and Chive. Product photo: Amazon

The story

In 2008 Tom Patterson was a medical device salesman in San Diego, in a suit every day and losing a daily battle with undershirts that stretched, yellowed and crept out of his trousers. With his wife, Erin Fujimoto, he sketched something longer and better fitted and took it to the tailor at their local dry cleaner.

The prototype cost him about $100 in fabric from the Los Angeles garment district and $50 in tailoring. The seamstress asked why any man would want an undershirt that looked like a dress. That autumn the recession took Patterson’s job. He read that a downturn is the best time to start a company, paid for the launch with his 401(k) and his credit cards, and patented what became the Stay-Tucked Undershirt. Underwear followed about a year later, and it is the underwear that made the name.

A few things worth knowing

The name

Everyone called him Tommy, and John is his middle name. No relation to the famous pitcher, although Patterson did pitch in junior high.

The first yes

Before pitching Neiman Marcus in 2009, Patterson sent samples to the buyer’s husband and her male colleagues. She launched the brand in 15 stores. Nordstrom followed.

The free endorsement

In 2014 Howard Stern praised it on air, unprompted. Patterson says it nearly broke the website, and he tells a good story that Stern wants to be buried in his Tommy John.

The co-owner

Kevin Hart bought a pair on the road, danced in them on Instagram and, in 2016, invested in the company.

The women asked

For ten years it was men only. Customers asked for a women’s line, and by 2023 it made up about 45% of sales.

The count

More than 30 million pairs sold, by the brand’s own count.

What sets it apart

Four details define a pair of Tommy John, and they are the reason it has a place in my drawer.

The Quick Draw fly. A horizontal opening rather than the usual vertical one. I love it. In work clothes or formal attire it makes a trip to the gents a breeze, and if you would rather not use it, it stays out of the way.

The Contour Pouch. Every pair of the men’s underwear has it: a curved front that Tommy John says supports and flatters your natural shape. Some lines offer the Hammock Pouch instead, which adds two inner panels of Air mesh for separation and extra hold. I have tried it, and it is not really my thing. So many brands now offer their own version that it is still worth exploring to see if it is yours.

The Stay-Put waistband. It is meant not to roll, bunch or pinch, and in my experience it keeps its word. Nothing creeps up or bunches through the day, whatever the day involves, and years in, the waistbands have never turned to bacon.

The Best Pair Guarantee. If you are not satisfied with your first purchase, Tommy John will refund or exchange it, even if it has been worn. Clearance items are final sale.

Which fabric for which occasion

Every fabric has a time and a place in a man’s life, and I have enjoyed every one of them. Here is how they differ.

Second Skin

Modal with a little stretch: silky, soft and the brand’s biggest line. In a trunk, it is one of my two favorites. The everyday luxury.

Cool Cotton

Pima cotton with stretch. Tommy John says it keeps you two to three times cooler than regular cotton. My other favorite trunk, and the natural choice for long days and warm nights.

Air

An ultra-light mesh, about two ounces a pair. In a brief, it simply cannot be beaten, and it is very flattering on the body. Tommy John says it air dries in under four hours, which makes it the one to pack.

Second Skin Luxe Rib

Second Skin with a ribbed texture for extra airflow. The same softness, with a little more character.

360 Sport and DriComfort

The performance fabrics: moisture-wicking and built to move. The ones for strenuous days at the gym.

Ultra Soft Flex

Lenzing modal with a no-fly support pouch for a clean, smooth front.

The cuts, and how they flatter

You cannot go wrong with any of them. It all comes down to personal style.

The brief shapes the seat and the front very nicely. Tommy John’s briefs have good coverage and keep a flattering line front and back, without being too full cut or too skimpy.

The trunk, with its 4-inch leg, does the same with a little more fabric, framing the man rather than simply covering him. It is the pair I would hand any man first.

The boxer brief comes in a 6-inch mid-length and an 8-inch leg. The 6-inch hugs in all the right places. The 8-inch is simply too much fabric for my taste, though plenty of men prefer the extra length.

The boxer will always be the most modest choice, by design.

Support and presentation

A good pair should look as considered as the clothes over it. Tommy John’s boxer briefs and trunks hug the body in all the right places and make the front look as good as the rear. The ladies like them. The briefs give the most shape of all, and the boxers the least, which is exactly what some days call for.

If you want more emphasis, the Hammock Pouch is the brand’s answer, and its own advice is to save it for the weekend if you prefer something more modest at the office.

Fit and sizing

Sizing is true to Tommy John’s size chart and the measurements it lists. Measure, check the chart and trust it.

How it wears

Remarkably well. I still have pairs from many years ago that look and feel brand new: no fading, no tired waistbands. That said, retire your underwear every now and again. Hygiene first.

Best picks by occasion

I wear Tommy John at every hour of the day. These are the pairs I would reach for.

Tommy John Second Skin 4 inch trunk in Cabernet Fireside Plaid, product photoSecond Skin 4″ Trunk in Cabernet Fireside Plaid. Product photo: Amazon
Every day

Second Skin Trunk 4″

If a man could own only one pair, this is the one I would hand him. Soft, smooth and framed just right, it stays put from the first meeting to the last drink.

Tommy John Air Cool Mesh briefs in black, dress blues and quiet shade grey, product photoAir Cool Mesh Brief in Black, Dress Blues and Quiet Shade. Product photo: Amazon
Date night

Air Cool Mesh Brief

The right cut can be seductive, and this is it. Cut from Air, Tommy John’s ultra-light micro mesh at about two ounces a pair, it breathes like nothing else in the range, with a shape that flatters front and back.

Our review: Air Brief, 8.9 out of 10

Tommy John Cool Cotton mid-length 6 inch boxer brief in navy, product photoCool Cotton 6″ Boxer Brief in Navy. Product photo: Amazon
The office

Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6″

Cool through a long day, a 6-inch leg that stays down under tailored trousers, and the Quick Draw fly for when you are buttoned into a suit.

Our review: Cool Cotton Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6", 8.2 out of 10

Tommy John 360 Sport mid-length 6 inch boxer briefs in dress blues and turbulence grey, product photo360 Sport 6″ Boxer Brief in Dress Blues and Turbulence. Product photo: Amazon
The gym

360 Sport Mid-Length Boxer Brief 6″

Tommy John makes proper active underwear for strenuous days. The 360 Sport line is the one built for it, with four-way stretch and mesh cooling zones, per the brand.

A smooth front

Ultra Soft Flex Trunk 4″

Modal, a 4-inch leg and no fly at all, for the cleanest line under slim trousers.

Our review: Ultra Soft Flex Trunk 4", 8.5 out of 10

Tommy John woven boxers in Gents Dress Blues, Cabin Plaid Cerulean and Vertical Stripe Cerulean, product photoWoven Boxers in Gents Dress Blues, Cabin Plaid and Vertical Stripe. Product photo: Amazon
Most modest

Woven Boxer

Classic cotton boxers with a traditional fly. Easy, airy and the most discreet pair in the range.

Our review: Woven Boxer (3-Pack), 7.9 out of 10

For travel, pack the Air. For sleep, any of them will keep you cool; Cool Cotton is the natural choice.

Buying it for him

For the woman choosing for her man: the fabrics are all excellent and the colors and patterns are classic and timeless, so you really cannot go wrong. Get him what he likes, and stay with the cut he already wears. Then add a pair in whatever cut you would most like to see him in.

Not sure where to start? The Second Skin Trunk is the safest first pair, and the Best Pair Guarantee covers a first purchase. More ideas in our gift guide for him.

Against Saxx and Calvin Klein

I find Tommy John much more comfortable, and better for everyday wear, than either. It is a true closet staple.

Is it worth the money?

I am never sorry to pay full price for it. But Tommy John runs plenty of offers through the year, and I have seen discounts as steep as 50%, so the patient can do very well.

The verdict

Clean, sophisticated branding. No neon, no loud patterns, no chunky waistbands. Just very good underwear that fits as promised, stays where you put it and lasts for years.

Start with a Second Skin trunk. If you prefer a brief, make it Air. Then build the rest of the drawer around the occasions in your life.

Our Tommy John reviews

The Tommy John brand page, with prices and buyer ratings.

Sources

The story and brand details come from the sources above; Howard Stern’s burial wish is Tom Patterson’s account. The verdicts are our own.